Acceptance now names the discovery fact (console_fact_get fact key err,
returning the effective err channel name) so the clause is testable like
G-007's named facts. Detail file additions: "every -console site" is
satisfied at the module's documented resolution choke points
(console_spec_resolve, hybrid_console_spec, opt_console_* helpers,
spec_to_channelpair, shared PUNKARGS fragments) rather than by per-site
audit; the two consumer-shaped acceptance clauses' division of labour is
stated (internal diagnostics migration = first consumer, external consumer
= public emit form); G-001 backends wanting a distinct diagnostic stream
must set err explicitly (default merges into out); and
previous_stty_state_stderr stays as-is (stty-state restoration, orthogonal
to diagnostic routing).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
punk::console models two channels per console ({in out}); its own
diagnostics fall back to raw puts stderr and subshell/backend/theme goals
(G-001/G-008/G-009) inherit the dual-channel assumption. G-011 defines err
as an attribute of the canonical {in out} console identity: {in out err}
specs accepted everywhere -console is, a nullable err field on
opunk::Console, err defaulting to process stderr for the default console
and to the console's out channel elsewhere, console-directed diagnostics
and an emit-to-err path, and cross-thread discovery via console_fact_get.
Ownership/fact/mode-cache keys stay canonical {in out}, so the G-007 work
is untouched.
Detail file records the gap analysis, the rejected shapes (err-in-identity
triple key, scope-boundary-only, uniform err==out, unset-means-none) and
the G-001 sequencing interaction.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Julian Noble