User decision 2026-07-12: when the constructed-definition normalization
mechanism lands, define_docs converts from its interim left-margin
authoring to indented-plus-normalized authoring, remaining the
acceptance criterion's consumer proof as written. Left-margin authoring
via -unindentedfields stays a supported style proven by the rendering
tests, but is not the preferred style for define_docs itself.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
::punk::helptopic::define_docs now authors its help text at the left
margin and declares -unindentedfields {-help} on the generated @cmd line
(honoured as of punk::args 0.6.1, increment 1) and on the topic argument
line (a gate that existed all along but was never applied here).
Previously: the @cmd -help braced literal carried ~16 spaces of source
indent into the constructed definition (constructed defs get no
whole-block normalization, pinned P4 characterization), so the
Description block rendered continuations +12 right of the first line;
the \n-relative topic -help rendered its first line +4 (the injected
display prefix). Both blocks now render flush. Help text content
unchanged (manual ~70-col folding retained).
Verified in punk902z src (arg_error render + i help end-to-end);
punk::ns suite 53/53; make.tcl modules builds clean. Planning note
recorded in the goal detail file: the constructed-def normalization
increment picks its consumer proof (define_docs re-conversion vs
ensemble_subcommands_definition) when it lands.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
arg_error's cmd-help display transform (undent " "+help, max 4 - the
'#unindentedfields ?' todo site) is now gated by "-help" membership in the
@cmd line's -unindentedfields list, mirroring the existing per-argument
gate. The single transform site feeds both the table and string renderers,
so left-margin-authored @cmd help renders its first line flush with
continuations in both. @cmd -summary carries no indent transform in any
renderer, so -unindentedfields for -summary is vacuously honoured. No
in-tree definitions set -unindentedfields on @cmd - existing rendering is
unchanged. define doc for -unindentedfields now states where the option is
valid.
Tests: rendering_unindentedfields_cmd_help_GAP flipped to
rendering_unindentedfields_cmd_help (aligned expectation, both renderers
measured). Full punk::args suite 175 pass / 1 pre-existing skip / 0 fail;
punk::ns suite 53/53 (arg_error consumer); make.tcl modules builds clean
(tclsh 9.0.3).
Also: G-045 flipped proposed -> active (user direction 2026-07-12);
progress and remaining-work recorded in the detail file.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Finalises the G-062 achieved flip staged by the prior session (punkshell
0.12.1): LICENSE.txt (BSD-2-Clause, Julian Marcel Noble 2023-2026) at the
repo root, README/punkproject.toml/AGENTS.md license declarations, index
record to GOALS-archive.md and detail file to goals/archive/.
Archive-loss prevention, from the G-015 incident (its achieved-status
verification parenthetical was silently dropped by the 2026-07-11 two-tier
restructure's Status-line normalisation; the text is restored to the G-015
archive file's Notes with provenance):
- root AGENTS.md 'Doc Restructures': deleted-line conservation check before
committing bulk doc migrations, structured-field-normalisation hazard
(relocate prose to body sections first), moves separated from edits
- goals/AGENTS.md: lintable header field grammar (one line per field, bare
Status values), flip-time verification evidence recorded in the body, the
archive move content-identical, and a new archive-time reference sweep:
pending-tense mentions of the archived goal updated in the live tier, and
actionable archived notes pointed to from the affected live goal's Notes
- GOALS.md maintenance rules: achieved-flip clause extended to require the
evidence write-up and the reference sweep
Retroactive reference sweep over all 12 archived goals (25 live detail
files): pending-tense fixes (G-002 G-008 G-013 G-016 G-017 G-021 G-022
G-031 G-042 G-044 G-050 - G-017's Goal/Acceptance annotated as
gate-satisfied, contract meaning unchanged), forward pointers pushed from
archived notes (G-062 license-seeding follow-on -> G-012/G-027, G-037
vendorlib/vfs drift semantics -> G-024, G-058 static-baseline mechanism ->
G-005), and one 'Archived-goal references' Notes bullet per remaining
referencing file so every live mention of an archived goal is resolvable
without consulting the archive index.
scriptlib/developer/goals_lint.tcl (new, plain tclsh): validates detail-file
header grammar, strict status values in both tiers, orphan rules in both
directions, Status/Scope mirror consistency, plus an informational (never
fatal) warning for live files referencing an archived goal with no
achieved/archive marker - baseline now zero warnings. Root AGENTS.md
scriptlib/developer ownership note widened to cover developer utilities.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
- GOALS.md collapsed to summary entries (ID/status/title/Scope/detail pointer): 104.6KB -> 23KB so a full read stays cheap; Scope lines kept verbatim so path-grep goal discovery still works
- canonicality split: index canonical for ID/status/title/Scope, detail file canonical for Goal:/Acceptance:; all 61 detail-file headers reconciled from the index (fixes stale copies, e.g. G-036 detail acceptance predated the achieved rework), bodies preserved untouched
- detail files created for the three index-only goals G-017, G-034, G-054; every goal now has one
- 10 achieved goals (G-007 G-015 G-036 G-037 G-040 G-046 G-049 G-054 G-058 G-059) archived: summary records appended to GOALS-archive.md, detail files moved to goals/archive/; archive-on-flip replaces the ~30-achieved-entries trigger
- GOALS.md preamble/rules reworked: read workflow (read index in full, then detail files of scope-intersecting goals before editing), contract spans both tiers with proposal-first unchanged, next-free-ID counts the archive, achieved flip judged against the detail-file Acceptance and includes archiving
- progress convention codified from G-001 increment-1 practice: index entries carry status only, never progress; incremental progress lives in the detail file's ## Progress section (landed/remaining); achieved flip requires the remaining-work list resolved - a partial increment never flips a goal
- goals/AGENTS.md rewritten for the split (required 4-field header, one detail file per goal, orphan rules covering archive/); root AGENTS.md Child DOX Index + Repo-wide Notes updated; GOALS-archive.md preamble updated
- stale detail-file paths updated to goals/archive/ in src/lib/app-punkscript/punkscript.tcl (comment), runtimebash_wsl.test, wslprobe.tcl and the G-042 detail file; propagated copies (root lib/, src/vfs/_vfscommon.vfs, src/_build) left to refresh via normal build steps
- no project version bump: governance docs and source comments only, no user-visible shell behaviour
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Both user-approved, drafted from the 2026-07-09 characterization findings with
their acceptance criteria anchored to the pinned GAP tests.
- G-045 (authoring ergonomics): parser-recognised record continuation
(candidate: unquoted trailing -& with collision rules and an element-count
disambiguation alternative recorded), @cmd honouring -unindentedfields,
constructed (string-built) definitions able to opt into the whole-block
indent normalization file-style definitions get (de-hacking
::punk::helptopic::define_docs as the consumer proof), and the
braced-vs-quoted container quoting rules promoted from defquoting.test into
the define documentation.
- G-046 (deferred -help + fixes): headline item per user emphasis at approval
- argument resolution stops processing -help/display-only fields, deferring
their tstr expansion to display time with separate parse-vs-display caching
(per the existing in-source review note), for measurable first-parse gains
and fixing the reentrancy class reproduced with punk::ansi::mark_columns
(~3.94s first call: its -help calls a proc that calls mark_columns, whose
parse resolves the same still-resolving definition). Plus: @dynamic
second-round multiline paramindent alignment, prefix-normalization value
shape (list-wrap of backslash-containing choices), -return string renderer
cmd-help continuation alignment, and the misleading goodargs 'Bad number of
leading values...' prefix in 'i <cmd> <args>' output.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Julian Noble