Three deltas surfaced by the PATH-scrubbed clean-checkout demonstration:
- build.zig: default-entry re-export of build905.zig's build so the documented
plain 'zig build stage|bootstrap' works from the tracked suite dir (the
recipe keeps its versioned filename; staged flows still invoke it via
--build-file).
- critcl_zig.config + recipe: settings move under an EXPLICIT target
(win32-x86_64-zig) and the tcllibc step passes -target win32-x86_64-zig.
critcl otherwise chooses its build target by probing PATH for compilers -
with a gcc visible the config defaults engaged (why G-098's flow worked),
but the scrubbed environment fell back to critcl's builtin msvc 'cl'
target and all 25 accelerator modules failed with "couldn't execute cl".
Verified green in BOTH environments (scrubbed and normal PATH).
- build905.zig comptime gate: the stale 0.13-dev minimum becomes the actual
suite pin (0.16.0) with a message pointing at punk-getzig and the README
(acceptance: the recipe records the zig version it is written against).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
The whole pipeline now lives in the zig recipe; Tcl remains the tool exactly
where a tclsh is guaranteed to exist - run by the FRESHLY BUILT suite shell
as build steps:
- New steps (native-host builds): smoke (static shell patchlevel; zip shell
patchlevel + attached tzdata/autoload), tklib / tcllib (their own installers,
batch, -pkg-path as a cached output dir installed into the prefix, + package
smokes incl withdrawn-Tk tooltip), tcllibc (critcl driving zig cc via the
tracked critcl_zig.config, module list parsed from tcllib's version.tcl,
pinned-zig dir prepended to PATH, + accel smoke), test-gate (tools/
test_gate.tcl - the parsed-totals gate vs expected_test_failures.txt,
-Dtestargs passthrough).
- Package landing moves into the recipe proper: thread pkgIndex.tcl
(build_tclthread), tk pkgIndex.tcl (build_tk), and the tclvfs script package
incl .in-template substitution + dll (build_tclvfs_shared
install_tclvfs_package) - all hooked to the install step.
- Step scripts: tools/test_gate.tcl, tools/suite_smoke.tcl, tools/pkg_smoke.tcl
(run under the built shell; assertions live in Tcl).
- Two windows-childproofing findings encoded: built-shell Runs execute the
CACHED artifact (no ../lib/tcl9.0 beside it) so each such Run gets
TCL_LIBRARY pointed at the source tree's script library (the zip smoke
deliberately excluded - its attached library is the thing under test); and
cached (non-side-effect) Runs spawn with stdout IGNORED, leaving the tcl
child without a stdout channel ('can not find channel named "stdout"',
critcl's logging) - such runs capture stdout to give the child a real pipe
while keeping caching.
- suite.tcl: thinned to the fossil dev flow - fetch live checkouts (git kind
now handled in the main loop for critcl's pin), stage the recipe, delegate
to the staged steps (run_zig_steps; 'test' delegates to test-gate). Default
-steps and the bootstrap default grow to the full pipeline short of
test-gate. critcl_zig.config + expected_test_failures.txt join both staging
lists. Docs updated (README two-flow section, sources.config two-surface
header, overlay section); .gitignore learns .zig-cache/ and zig-pkg/ (zig
0.16 extracts fetched packages into zig-pkg/ beside the manifest).
Verified (fossil flow): full pipeline PASS - suite_smoke static+zip, tklib
tooltip:2.0.4 under withdrawn Tk, tcllib md5/sha1/cmdline, tcllibc:2.0 with
md5-critcl-accel:1; 'suite.tcl test -testargs {-file http.test}' delegates to
the gate step (528/519/9/0 GATE PASS).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
suite_tcl90 gains the no-tclsh source path:
- build.zig.zon: content-hashed manifest pinning each source as a fossil
per-checkin tarball (tcl 1a9c3b9d96 / thread caa1d3aa30 / tclvfs f082c47f9b
/ tk effef6c657 / tklib 2d53beafc0 / tcllib c784f6fda4 - the exact checkouts
the promoted punk905 runtime was built from) plus critcl 3.3.1 as a github
archive. All lazy: the fossil dev flow never triggers a fetch. Refresh =
bump a pin (zig fetch --save). Verified honored under --build-file
build905.zig.
- build905.zig mode split: from the staged recipe copy the full graph
registers as before; from the TRACKED suite dir (sources.config present,
no ../tcl905) only the staging steps register. 'zig build stage'
materializes pinned sources + a recipe copy into ../_build/<suite> (the
same layout suite.tcl's fossil staging produces - both flows share the
staged invocation, and the stage dir derives from the suite folder name so
copy-and-tweak isolation holds). 'zig build bootstrap' chains the staged
build: nested zig invocation with suite.tcl-parity cwd (parts of the
recipe resolve sources cwd-relative), forward-slash prefix (the prefix
flows into -DTCL_PACKAGE_PATH as a C string literal - backslashes broke
the stubs compile), per-zig-version shared cache dir, hermetic-child env
scrub, ReleaseFast default.
- tools/stagetree.zig: host-compiled materializer. Pinned mode keys a
.stage-materialized marker on the dependency's content-addressed cache
path (pin bump = invalidation, stale trees deleted so orphans cannot
survive); always-mode for recipe items; fossil/git checkouts at the
destination are never touched (tested).
Verified: 'zig build stage' against the fossil-populated stage refreshes
only the recipe copy (checkouts untouched, fossil changes empty); a full
copy-and-tweak suite copy (suite_tcl90zt) ran 'zig build bootstrap' from
nothing but the tracked tree + pinned zig - all 7 sources fetched/staged
from the manifest, all four shells built; tcl::build-info reports the same
9.0.5+1a9c3b9d... as the fossil-flow build and the zip shell boots its
attached library (tzdata + autoload).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Generation of the configure-products a fresh checkout lacks moves from
suite.tcl tree-writes into the zig recipe as build-cache overlays:
- tclUuid.h / tkUuid.h / threadUuid.h: wrapfiletofile Run outputs consumed
via overlay include dirs added FIRST per module (stale tree copies from
pre-G-102 flows can never shadow; the LazyPath also carries the step dep).
The unused addUpdateSourceFiles tree-write variants (build905 prepare-source,
build_tclthread) are removed.
- tclsh.exe.manifest: configure-time substitution (tcl.h parsed by the new
build_common.zig helpers); tclsh.rc compiled from an overlay COPY beside the
generated manifest because rc resource references resolve rc-file-relative
before include paths. Both tclsh exes switch to .include_paths LazyPaths.
- wish.exe.manifest: overlay dir first in tk.rc include_paths (RT_MANIFEST
resolves through rc include paths - the arrangement the tk build already
relied on). tk.rc itself stays tree-compiled (lives in win/rc, no stale risk).
- thread.rc: compiled from an overlay copy with the tcl.h include inserted
(the historical checkout edit is normalized if a mutated tree is staged);
the staged tclthread checkout's thread.rc edit has been fossil-reverted.
- build905.zig: redundant configure-time top-level library install loop
removed (install_library_tree already covers it); dead zlib stage copy and
the suite.tcl generation blocks removed (read-only version parsing kept for
smokes/logging).
Verified: full staged-mode rebuild PASS (all smokes incl tklib/tcllib/tcllibc);
built binaries carry the overlay products (tcl::build-info reports
9.0.5+1a9c3b9d..., tclsh manifest version 9.0.2.905, tk dll manifest + tk
checkout uuid, thread dll uuid; thread dll's empty FileVersion matches the
pre-change binary - upstream quirk). Source checkouts stay pristine (fossil
changes empty). Core test gate: 69783 run, 12 failed - 11 baselined plus
http-4.14.2, a network-timing flake that passes on isolated rerun (528/519/9/0).
tclsh90sprzip.exe install into out/bin is currently blocked by an open user
application holding the file; the product builds identically into the zig
cache and installs on next run once released.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
User direction 2026-07-21 recorded in G-103: piperepl-patched runtime
executables must carry 'punk' in the name (e.g tclsh905punk.exe) so
patched and unpatched are never confusable - now an Acceptance item, with
the open design questions captured (how to encode tcl patchlevel + punk
version, separator choice; existing sub-namespaces punkNNN kits /
tclsh-runtimes / punk- utilities; metadata carries authoritative versions
so filenames stay human-distinguishing). The suite's tclsh90spr/sprzip
are flagged as internal working names in patches/README.md pending the
scheme.
Also noted: punkbin pushes of suite runtimes are deferred until family
members carry Thread etc in the attached zip and the punk-named pr
variants exist - publication follows G-103's artifacts, not the interim
tclsh905/punk905 shapes. goals_lint clean.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Fresh clone (shallow path + core.longpaths - the deep-path first attempt
hit windows MAX_PATH on the modpod template trees, caveat recorded) ->
the clone's own punk-getzig fetched 0.16.0 (mirror chain, minisign,
versioned dir) -> cold-cache suite build PASS: 9.0.5 static/zip/pr/przip
shells with recipe-generated configure-products, zip shell smoked, all
tk/tklib/tcllib/tcllibc legs green.
Cold-log 'failed command:' blocks diagnosed as BENIGN zig 0.16 behaviour
(build_runner prints that block for any step with nonempty result_stderr
even on success) triggered by our own tools' informational stderr prints
- zipfs_mkzip/mkimg call echoes now go to stdout and wrapfiletofile's
octet count is removed; rebuild shows zero occurrences, PASS.
All G-096 acceptance items are now met - achieved flip pending user
confirmation.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
The recovered 2024 TCLSH_PIPEREPL patch applies cleanly to current
core-9-0-branch tclMain.c (8 hunks, offset 4). Tracked as
patches/tclMain_piperepl_905.c = stock 9.0.5 + patch + gate-default flip:
ENABLED unless TCLSH_PIPEREPL=0 (2024 was opt-in set-and-not-"0") per the
G-103 punk-kit policy - the goal's Goal/Acceptance were aligned to that
policy first at user request. Era files kept unmodified as recovered
artifacts; patches/README updated (status, gate semantics, known
tcl_interactive early-link divergence when the gate is open).
build905.zig gains tclsh90spr (per-source construction mirroring tclsh90s
with both tclMain compiles - unicode + TCL_ASCII_MAIN ansi - swapped to
the patched file; stock products stay byte-for-byte unpatched) and
tclsh90sprzip (zipfs_mkimg wrap of the pr exe, -infile form). patches/
added to suite.tcl's staged recipe items. Full suite build PASS.
Behaviour matrix recorded in the goal: 9/9 stock-equivalence rows
IDENTICAL (script-arg / script-consuming-stdin / piped-commands x
unset/0/1 - open-gate plain scripts behave stock; unread piped payload
never eval'd); feature row proves buffering verbatim into
::tclsh(inputbuffer) (write-trace capture), console reopen success and
repl landing; =0 feature row identical to stock; przip variant identical
to pr - the G-103 punk-kit precursor works.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
A developer (no llm assistance, no punkshell modules - the driver stays
dependency-free plain tclsh) can now copy the suite tree and retarget
sources declaratively: urls/refs/pins live in sources.config (plain line
records 'source <name> <kind> <url> <ref> <dir>', parsed never executed;
fossil sources + the critcl git pin), and the build stage derives from the
suite FOLDER name so a copied tree stages into its own _build/<name>
isolated from the original. -tclbranch becomes a per-run override of the
declared tcl ref. Depth limit documented where the tweaker will read it:
same-major url/ref changes are config-only; version-class changes ripple
into build905.zig (checkout dir names, version-derived tm/dll/manifest
names).
README gains a Retargeting/copying section; its Sources section corrected
(stale per-stage fossil-store location from before the ~/.punkshell/fossils
move, and the G-098 sources were missing from the table).
Direction recorded in G-096 notes (2026-07-20): toml requirement DROPPED
for binary-build buildsuites; long-term intent is bootstrapping without a
pre-existing tclsh (zig acquisition = accepted root dependency; the
freshly built tclsh is the legitimate intermediate for tcllib/tklib
installers and critcl); zig-driver-vs-polyglot question recorded with the
current recommendation (zig hybrid; polyglot counselled against).
Verified: suite.tcl test -testargs '-file assocd.test' passes through
config load + fetch skip-logic + gate on the existing stage; stage
derivation for a copied name resolves to _build/<copyname>.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
suite.tcl 'test' is now a gate: full tcltest output logged, totals parsed
(all.tcl's exit code does not reflect failures), failed test names compared
against expected_test_failures.txt - unexplained failures fail the action;
stale baseline entries are noted on full runs. Totals on core-9-0-branch
9.0.5 / zig 0.16.0: 67281 run / 55835 passed / 11435 skipped / 11 failed,
GATE PASS, deterministic across two full runs. The 11 are dispositioned in
the baseline: 6 fCmd (OS username vs profile-dir machine trait), 2 filename
(admin-share self-globbing), 2 safe-stock (install-layout accessPath
tokens), 1 console-bug-f10d91c2 (powershell driver yields empty result in
batch context; semantics verified independently by G-076 kill procedure).
Runtime package plumbing gaps closed (built artifacts without install
wiring): thread pkgIndex generated (lib/thread3.0.1 -> bin dll), registry
dll install artifact hooked to install-libraries (was orphaned - registry
1.3.7 + dde 1.4.6 now load), tclvfs script package installed with vfs.tcl
+ pkgIndex.tcl generated from .in templates (vfs 1.4.2 + vfs::zip 1.0.4).
punkshell runtests under the suite runtime: checkbugs 5/5, opunk
backends.test PASS (Tk-widget console suite runs unskipped on the
suite-built Tk), repl consolebackends 2/3 - repl_console_backend_tkconsole
open (code-interp console_pending_out junction init missing; DRIVER-DONE
timeout-failsafe).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
tcllib pure side via its own installer (explicit -pkg-path; driver now unsets
TCLLIBPATH/TCL_LIBRARY/TK_LIBRARY for hermetic child shells after the default
libdir followed inherited TCLLIBPATH to C:/TCLPKGS - additive pollution
verified and removed). install-libraries now installs the whole tcl library
tree (its own pkgIndex references msgcat/opt/... subdirs the piecemeal
install missed). critcl pinned 3.3.1 (git) + tracked critcl_zig.config
(zig cc -target x86_64-windows-gnu); driver replicates sak's direct critcl
invocation over the 21 declared files -> tcllibc.dll at out/lib/tcllibc
(provide 2.0). Evidence: md5 accel(critcl)=1; sha1 5MB critcl 12.3ms vs
pure 3.06s (~248x) - the punkcheck hashing pain quantified and fixed.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Installer behaviour checked first per user caveat: module exclusions,
app-script generation, doc options, and the aggregating top-level
pkgIndex.tcl (gen_main_index) - not a straight copy; critcl DSL stubbed to
no-ops (pure-tcl). Driver runs it with the suite-built tclsh in batch mode,
packages only, landing out/lib/tklib0.9. Smoke: package require Tk +
tooltip -> 2.0.4 in the suite shell.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
The build016 experiment port lands in the tracked recipe (root_module/
createModule creation, addLibrary+linkage, .root_module.* method sweep,
linkSystemLibrary options arg, array_list.Managed, Io.Dir dir-walks with
b.graph.io, wrapfiletofile ported to the 0.16 entry/Io idiom). 0.14 support
deprecated per user direction; 0.14.1 remains archived on punkbin. Verified
on the pinned default (bin/tools/zig-x86_64-windows-0.16.0): build PASS,
shells 9.0.5, tcl-test parity 557/357/200/0 identical to the 0.14.1 build.
punk-getzig payload pins -> 0.16.0 (windows zip + linux tarball), re-wrapped
checkfile ERROR-free, ps1 twin refreshed. punkbin commit 54714d7 holds the
0.16.0 archive; push pending gitea recovery (server currently 500s).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
vqtcl was an old-tclkit experiment with no confirmed public upstream - wiring,
helper module, staging and docs removed (future tclkit work: TEMP_REFERENCE/
metakit + KitCreator). New 'test' action runs tests/all.tcl on the suite-built
static shell with -testargs passthrough; verified assocd/util/lindex: 557 run,
357 passed, 200 constraint-skipped (no C test commands in a release shell),
0 failed. install-libraries tm filenames synced to the tree's provided
versions (tcltest-2.5.11, http-2.10.2, platform-1.1.1) - the 2024-era names
made 'package require tcltest' fail on a filename/provide version conflict.
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Recipe: b.host -> b.graph.host; redundant second UNICODE tclMain add into the
objs lib removed; exe's ansi tclMain compiled with -UUNICODE -U_UNICODE
-DTCL_ASCII_MAIN (zig cc windows-default defines made it a duplicate UNICODE
compile under 0.14.1 - lld duplicate Tcl_MainExW/commons). Driver: per-item
recipe staging, per-zig-version local caches (.zig-cache-<ver>; caches must
not be shared across zig versions), zig resolution -zig > PUNK_ZIG > pinned
bin/tools/zig-x86_64-windows-0.14.1 > PATH. Verified: PASS on 0.14.1 AND
regression PASS on 0.14.0-dev.2074; pinned-default no-option run PASS.
Pinned archive minisign-verified and published to punkbin (abcd87c).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
First real buildsuite: build905.zig (verbatim G-076-validated recipe) +
helper modules + tools, driven by suite.tcl which stages the recipe into
src/buildsuites/_build/suite_tcl90, arranges sources (tcl fossil
core-9-0-branch --nested with FOSSIL_HOME isolation; thread/tclvfs trunk;
zlib from the tcl tree's compat/zlib; vqtcl from a local dir), generates the
configure-products fresh checkouts lack (tclUuid.h, tclsh.exe.manifest,
thread.rc include), builds and smoke-tests. Verified PASS: static + zip
shells report 9.0.5 (checkout 1a9c3b9d96), Thread 3.0.1 builds from current
trunk (new generated-include fix in build_tclthread) and loads. The 2024
TCLSH_PIPEREPL/tclZipfs/tclCmdIL patches are now tracked under
suite_tcl90/patches with a semantics README (not applied by default builds).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Blanket /src/buildsuites ignores removed from .gitignore and
.fossil-settings/ignore-glob; retired /vendorbuilds/ ignores removed with
them. src/buildsuites/_build remains ignored via the existing _build globs.
samplesuite1 sketch marked as such, buildprefix moved to the _build
convention (vendorbuild concept retired per user decision 2026-07-20).
Assisted-by: harness=claude; primary-model=claude-fable-5; api-location=anthropic.com
Julian Noble